Tundra on the Ground in Brazil: Pessimism Has Gone Too Far

In November, Tundra portfolio manager Simon Sidmalm travelled to São Paulo to meet with companies and gain firsthand insights into the market following Brazil’s turbulent presidential election. Brazilian equities initially rallied sharply, with the Ibovespa index surging more than 14% after Flávio Bolsonaro secured the most votes in the first round. However, the subsequent reversal was even more dramatic as incumbent President Lula da Silva staged an unexpected comeback to win the runoff election. Lula had been all but written off by prediction markets, which had assigned Bolsonaro an 80% probability of victory heading into the second round.

Brazil’s presidential election takes place over two rounds. In the first round, voters can choose from all presidential candidates. If no candidate secures more than 50% of the vote, the two leading candidates advance to a second round.
In this year’s election, Bolsonaro received 47.0% of the vote in the first round, compared with Lula’s 45.2%. In the runoff, however, Lula secured 51.8% against Bolsonaro’s 48.2%.
The market’s initial enthusiasm for a potential change in government was largely driven by Bolsonaro’s promises to address the substantial fiscal deficit that has weighed on Brazil’s economy and pushed interest rates higher. Brazil’s benchmark Selic rate currently stands at 13.75%, and with inflation at 4.6%, the country has one of the highest real interest rates in the world, exceeding 9%. Beyond discouraging corporate borrowing and investment, these high interest rates have also drawn capital away from the equity market. Quite simply, investors have had strong incentives to favour government bonds over equities when interest rates have been this high. In addition to significant cuts in public spending, Bolsonaro also promised tax reductions and further privatisation of state-owned enterprises.
These hopes were dashed when Lula was re-elected for a fourth presidential term. The 81-year-old political veteran, who first took office in 2003, pledged during his campaign to maintain the existing fiscal framework, expand social welfare programmes and raise taxes. This raised concerns among investors that Brazil’s public finances could deteriorate further.
During our visit, we spoke with local analysts and asset managers who painted a deeply pessimistic picture of the post-election environment. One local portfolio manager suggested that he would essentially withdraw from the Brazilian equity market for the next four years and "perhaps return in mid-2029, ahead of the next election." Our impression is that expectations of a political shift had become so elevated that the disappointment was particularly severe when the anticipated outcome failed to materialise.
The companies we met, however, offered a somewhat more balanced perspective. While many expressed disappointment with the election result, the general impression was that business would continue much as usual, regardless of whether Lula or someone else was in power. Then again, what CEO would paint an overly bleak picture when speaking with investors?
Nevertheless, our sense is that the pessimism among local investors has become excessive. Brazil is home to many excellent companies that are growing rapidly, generating strong margins and trading at attractive valuations. At the time of writing, companies in the Ibovespa index trade at an average of just nine times annual earnings. We believe sentiment will gradually improve as the market comes to realise that Lula is unlikely to pursue reckless fiscal policies that would severely undermine the government’s finances.
As one company executive put it, "If you expect interest rates to remain at their current levels over the long term, you probably shouldn't own anything in Brazil." We do not share that expectation. At some point, conditions should begin to normalise. If developments turn out even slightly better than the pessimists anticipate, the current environment could present an exceptional opportunity to acquire high-quality Brazilian companies at attractive valuations.
Meeting with Smart Fit
During our visit, we met with around 20 companies, including both new investment prospects and existing portfolio holdings. One of these was gym operator Smart Fit, which we hold in our discretionary Global Emerging Markets (GEM) mandate.
Smart Fit operates more than 2,200 gyms across Latin America, primarily in Brazil and Mexico, and has close to 5.7 million members. The company is growing by 25–30% annually, driven both by the opening of new gyms and, increasingly, by membership growth through its corporate wellness platform, TotalPass.
Through TotalPass, employers pay a fixed fee per employee to provide access to Smart Fit’s own gyms as well as a network of independently operated partner gyms. This represents an asset-light growth opportunity with several advantages. The low marginal cost of adding new members supports higher operating margins, while access to third-party gyms allows the company to expand without committing significant capital to new facilities. At the same time, the platform strengthens Smart Fit’s competitive position beyond the ownership and operation of physical gyms, a business that is otherwise highly competitive.
We had the opportunity to meet with the company’s new CFO, José Luiz Rizzardo, who took up his position earlier this year, to discuss recent developments and the company’s strategy going forward. A key strategic priority is the continued expansion of TotalPass, which now has more members on its platform than Smart Fit has direct-to-consumer (B2C) members in Brazil.
Smart Fit’s new CFO, José Luiz Rizzardo, with Tundra portfolio manager Simon Sidmalm.
On the Ground – The Rise of K-Beauty
Visiting our local markets is about much more than sitting in conference rooms with company management teams. These trips also provide valuable opportunities to observe trends and developments beyond the meeting rooms.
One such observation was the growing popularity of K-Beauty across Latin America. We already invest in Korean cosmetics companies benefiting from explosive growth in Europe and the US, but Latin America is now emerging as another important growth driver.
In most pharmacies we visited, we found dedicated shelves for "Beleza Asiática" – Asian beauty products – with a strong presence of K-Beauty brands. Brazil’s largest pharmacy chain, Raia Drogasil, has also recently launched a dedicated beauty store, where Asian beauty products occupy an entire aisle.
Asian Beauty section at a Pague Menos pharmacy.
Capital invested in a fund may either increase or decrease in value and it is not certain that you be able to recover all of your investment. Historical return is no guarantee of future return. The state of origin of the Fund is Sweden. This information may only be distributed in or from Switzerland to qualified investors within the meaning of Art. 10 Para. 3,3bis and 3ter CISA. The representative in Switzerland is OpenFunds Investment Services AG, Seefeldstrasse 35, 8008 Zurich, whilst the Paying Agent is Società Bancaria Ticinese SA, Piazza Collegiata 3, 6501 Bellinzona, Switzerland. The Basic documents of the fund as well as the annual report may be obtained free of charge at the registered office of the Swiss Representative.



